Walnut Hill, Fla. woman turns self in on possession of forged instrument, theft warrants

Published 1:26 pm Tuesday, June 13, 2023

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

A Walnut Hill, Fla. woman turned herself into the Escambia County Detention Center in Brewton on June 13 on possession of forged instrument and theft warrants, according to the Atmore Police Department.


Public Information Officer Sgt. Darrell McMann said in a release that Paula Pugh, 48, who had been under investigation in reference to financial theft from Northwest Escambia Bradberry Park in Walnut Hill, has been charged with theft of property I and III and possession of a forged instrument.

McMann said on May 31, an APD investigator was contacted by the case investigator of the Escambia County Sheriff’s Office (Fla.) in reference to Pugh.

Sign up for our daily email newsletter

Get the latest news sent to your inbox

“Pugh had been under investigation in reference to financial theft from Northwest Escambia Bradberry Park in Walnut Hill, Fla.,” McMann said. “The investigation was transferred to the Atmore Police Department due to the transactions that were completed at First National Bank (and Trust) in Atmore.”

McMann said the investigator reviewed the financial records and witness statements in the case file provided to him by the Escambia County FL Sheriff’s Office investigator.

McMann said warrants for Pugh were obtained for nine counts of possession of a forged instrument III, one count of theft by deception I and one count of theft by deception II.


According to Atmore Advance archives, Pugh in April was charged with fraud (swindle), obtaining property under $20,000, and larceny, grand theft of $10,000 or less than $20,000, according to an ECSO (Fla.) warrant report.

According to the report, between July 26, 2021 to Dec. 9, 2022, Pugh allegedly wrote checks on NWE’s account, cashed them for personal use; completed unauthorized debit transactions for personal use; and completed numerous ATM withdrawals for personal use. The transactions totaled $16,977.87.

According to the report, there were numerous transactions allegedly completed by Pugh that haven’t been backed up by receipt or other account records. The transactions include ATM withdrawals from an Atmore bank, items purchased at a Dicks Sporting Goods, NWE checks made to cash and signed by Pugh, allegedly; to name a few.

According to the report, NWE president of the ballpark John Maughon filed a report with the ECSO in reference to the misuse of funds. The ECSO then collected bookkeeping records, and went over said records with John and Bonnie Maughon to place them into evidence, according to the report.

From the interview, ECSO investigators were able to compile the itemized list.

Additionally, during the investigation, records indicated that a ball tournament that was completed on June 13, 2022, at NWE ballpark, yielded a receipt/cash profit totaling $10,012.66, according to the report.

According to the report, the books were secured from Pugh, and after numerous attempts were made to contact Pugh that went unanswered, the ECSO made contact with Pugh and she agreed to meet with them on the matter. A sworn and recorded interview with Pugh was conducted.

Pugh, who is listed as a teacher at Northview High School, was booked into the Escambia County (Fla.) Jail in Pensacola at approximately 5:15 p.m. on April 17. She made bond some 20 minutes later.



Editor’s note: The Northwest Escambia Little League isn’t affiliated with Northwest Escambia (NWE) Football and Cheer league.